We’re living in a golden age of television. We have been for at least 20 years now and with the power of platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney+ and Apple TV, investment in ensuring this golden age continues is at an all time high.
When critics look back over the last 20 or 30 years of TV, and in particular shows considered classic box-set, binge-watch favourites, at least 20 shows always feature in Top 50 lists. I don’t need to name them all, you know what they are by know. But with this list I wanted to concentrate on shows that lasted the perfect length of time and never outstayed their welcome or let the quality slip.
Let me get to the nitty-gritty and list some brilliant, mind blowingly influential shows that won’t make this list. First up there’s no room for Breaking Bad. The drab, made for Netflix, El Camino revisit put paid to that. Mad Men doesn’t make it as it lost it’s sparkle after Season 4. Twin Peaks is out of contention due to the original TV series being too old. The last season of Game of Thrones means it doesn’t make the list. One of my all-time favourite shows, Lost gets excluded because of a saggy season 3 and a confusing last season (that I eventually grew to love but had issues with initially). Fringe and 30 Rock faltered a bit towards the end and classic sit-coms like Seinfeld, Friends, Cheers are obviously too old.
Before I reveal Slacker Shack’s Top Five, here’s a few comedy shows that came very close but didn’t make it (let the arguments commence) – Peep Show (I always wanted more of it and felt it didn’t have the impact it could’ve had because of that), Curb Your Enthusiasm (a couple of average seasons meant it was close but no cigar), The US Office (I loved this show but it sagged badly in it’s last couple of seasons), Flight of the Conchords (an all-time favourite of mine, but it could’ve and should’ve stayed around a lot longer) and (this breaks my heart) probably my all-time favourite sit-com, Parks and Recreation (because of its average first season).
No more waffling, here’s our ‘Top Five 21st century TV shows that knew the perfect time to quit‘:
Number 5 is Fleabag. I know it’s not to everyone’s taste, I have a few friends who thought it was awful, but for me it was a perfect zeitgeisty slice of 21st century comedy. It only lasted for twelve episodes, which to American audiences is barely a season, but unlike other recent comedies that have either overstayed their welcome (Arrested Development, Modern Family) or had ‘quality wobbles’ (Community, It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia) it had a well thought out structure to it and seemed the absolute perfect length.
Number 4, Mackenzie Crook‘s recent comedy, Detectorists, has been a bit of a sleeper hit over the past twelve months, with lots of new fans checking it out during lockdown. Brilliantly acted and beautifully gentle and understated I fell in love with it back in May and binge watched all of it in a fortnight. At only 19 episodes longer some may argue it could’ve lasted longer but for me it was a perfectly paced dip into two men’s metal detector based friendship, and a show I know I’ll revisit from time to time when I just want to lie back and softly chuckle.
This might’ve made our number one spot but for possibly 2 or 3 needless episodes in the last season. In at Number 3 is The Sopranos. I came to the show very late and watched it over a three month period earlier this year. All the hype felt justified and whilst I don’t think it’s “the greatest TV show ever made“, it never felt saggy and even at whopping 86 episodes long it never outstayed it’s welcome – it was utterly captivating from start to finish and masterfully paced.
Our Number 2 pick might be potentially contentious to die-hard fans of Tom Perrota‘s source novel, as it expands on his book and takes it somewhere different, but for me The Leftovers is one of the greatest pieces of television ever made. A pretty bold statement but it really left a mark on me and emotionally affected me unlike any other show I’ve seen in the past twenty years. I’ve always loved what I call ‘earth based sci-fi’ and the mysterious and mesmerising story of Kevin Garvey is electrifying from start to finish. Like Lost, Twin Peaks, Fringe and recent German hit, Dark, The Leftovers revels in bending your mind in all kinds of different directions, but it’s magic lies in the journey it takes your heart on too. At it’s core it’s a love story and a perfectly paced one at 3 seasons and 28 episodes long.
It’s no real surprise to see HBO‘s The Wire at the Number 1 spot (maybe it’s even a bit boring – soz). It’s ingenious idea of examing the way a city (in its case Baltimore) works and functions from different perspectives, gave it a masterful structure. From the urban ghettoes to the docks and from the schools and newspaper to City Hall, it offered a fascinating insight into diverse worlds, all interlinked and co-exisiting in one city. It’s writing is peerless and characters like Stringer Bell, Jimmy McNulty, Bubbles, Omar Little and Avon Barksdale have made an indelible mark on popular modern culture. It’s 60 episodes seemed perfect.
So, that’s our top five. There was no space for shows like Better Call Saul, Ozark and Fargo as they’re still running – but all three could be in with a shout in the future as they’re all excellent. What would make your top five?